That's the question that keeps rolling through my head.
Saturday, riding the E train back to my apartment with wife and two college-aged children, we had a pack of nine kids enter the train. They were ages 15-18 I'd guess, and they were loud. At first, I thought, no big deal, kids are loud, they're having good fun. They're obnoxious, but no biggie.
Then they got more animated. And more foul-mouthed. They started shouting back and forth through the car about "f-ing someone's mother" and other offensive stuff I'd rather not type. My wife was sittingthere. My 19-year-old daughter was sittingthere. I was getting more and more ticked off.
Those who know me well know I'm the most non-confrontational guy there is. I hate confrontation. I'll walk out of a bank if my wife's arguing with the teller about a problem. I just don't like it.
So 999 times out of a thousand, I would just let these kids go on offending everyone in the car, keep my head down and let it go. Like almost every New Yorker does.
Except I didn't. I stood up.
I thought the simple of act of standing up and glaring at several of the kids would be enough to make them realize they were out of line and tone it down. No such luck. 16-year-olds are many things, and one of them is oblivious. More obscenities. So I walked to the corner of the car where four of the nine were standingand asked one of them under my breath, not to call them out, "Hey, I know you kids are just having a good time, but would you mind taking your party up to the next car?"
You'd have thought I'd asked him to shoot his sister. He gave me a look like he couldn't believe what I'd said. Then he cursed at me. Then as his friends figured out what had happened, they joined in, cursing and telling me they weren't going anywhere.
"You apparently didn't hear what I said," I said, more loudly now, and more ominously and threateningly. "I know you're just having fun, but go do it in the next car."
Now all hell broke loose. I had a pack of kids all yelling an screaming about how they weren't going anywhere. I was called a cracker. I stayed calm, knowing from my training as a football official not to let the situation escalate. As we pulled into the next station I looked over the shoulders of two of the kids through the doorway window into the next car, acted like I'd made eye contact and made a subtle gesture with my finger calling some nonexistent person up and pointing at the kids. It was subtle but convinced at least three of them that an enforcement officer might be in the next car and might be heading our way. They took the bait, and at least half of the kids jumped outside the doors and started calling for their friends to join them.
After a lot more name-calling and yelling -- none of which I returned or responded to -- they were all outside the door and I waited for it to close. But before it could, one of them reached down into their pocket and pulled out a small one-inch buck knife and started waving it at me through the open doorway. He made one slashing movement at me, which I didn't even have to dodge and then the door started closing. The train moved out and I calmly sat back down at my seat.
My wife was more amused than startled by the whole incident. My son had stayed calm on the other side of the car until he saw the knife, then had jumped up to cover my back. My daughter was quite shaken up, and scolded me -- perhaps rightly -- for getting involved rather than just letting the whole thing go.
So that's the internal debate I'm still having. Was I brave? Was I stupid? Was I right to get my hillbilly sensibilities up and shoo the toughs off the train? Or did I risk my life foolishly. I'm pleased to note that at no time were my wife and kids in any danger. And at the time, until the knife showed up, I didn't really feel I was. I was calm and in control. But it was so unlike me that I still don't know why I did it.
But was I brave? Or stupid? Hit the comments section and let me know what you think.
Recent Comments